Had this comissioned.
Headband is an official headband I purchased off of Amazon.
Scroll is made of a roll of furniture foam wrapped in green fabric around a cardboard tube and painted on the sides. Used manilla style rope to give it a more authentic feel. Couldn't find exactly what Jiraiya's scroll has written on it so I opted for "Looking for a Japanese girlfriend" in Japanese.
Bought the geta sandals in Little Tokyo, LA and painted them primary red myself. They definitely need to be padded for next year; they were murder on my feet.
Finally, I cosplayed as a manga/anime character, it only took me 5 years to get around to one!
Uh, more hugs from girls than any other costume I've worn award?