I do like the idea of a whole thread dedicated to the list, but I don't have the panel for locking and unlocking threads and it would be pretty impossible to keep confused people out of it.
Maybe saving the first two pages, like mentioned, and then have everyone start posting reviews in the new thread with all the old ones linking back to this one? I'm not sure if this thread will disappear if it goes unused or what.
I'll PM the powers that be about getting a replacement thread stickied and if I haven't heard anything in a week or so I'll go ahead and make it anyway. They'll figure it out when it shows up in the forum, I guess.
Thanks for the ideas!