Thank you, love.
I ended up ordering the darker one since I know that the lighter one is actually pretty darn red. I wanted to order an Anytime Hawk wig from Amphigory, but they don't sell them anymore, and neither does the original company. Shammmeeeeee. We'll have to see how it goes. I may or may not have bought a Castiel trench today too... so I'll be searching for his wig too~!
I'm also in the market for Dean's green/olive cargo jacket. I found one in black, but... nope.