Same here! I recently deleted my previous avatar to see if that would do anything but it's not working. It won't even let me use the previous image again and it's so frustrating.
Edit: Oh look, it's showing up again. Weird.
Resident Mustache Warper
Vriska Serket - God Tier [Homestuck] 50%
Vriska Serket - Assassin!Tier [Homestuck] 25%
Raimei Shimizu [Nabari no Ou] 15% [Hiatus]
Calliope [Homestuck] 15%
Claudia Auditore - Assassin [Assassin's Creed] 0%
I dream of getting rid of that icon someday. Prayer circle for me.