Gave it another try tonight. Still scary. I think I need to work on the eyeshadow. :-)
I tried out the Revlon Colorstay, but I'm starting to wonder if I'm using the right foundation for my skintone. On the one hand I'm very 'pinkish', especially on skin that is under my clothes. However, I tan much more than I burn, and actually, even at the end of winter, have something of a farmer's tan.
The foundation just looked 'wrong' tonight.
I had a bit more success with covering my eyebrows, but I still could easily see the hairs. What was more annoying though was that after covering them with foundation it didn't seem like anything else would 'stick' to that part of my face.