Hey guys, thanks for the suggestions!
Psy-chan - Ooh, thanks for the youtube recs. I have been looking at several makeup tutorials there but haven't found many that are particularly helpful. I'll give those a watch and see what I can come up with. By "subtle eyeliner", do you mean using a color other than black? xD Yeah clearly I know nothing about makeup.
Throatriptron - Eek, that doesn't sound like it would be good for my skin. Would bronzer be okay to use on arms, too? Do you have any tips on keeping it from rubbing off onto clothing and whatnot?