Department store lip liners should work. I used to have toxic red hair (my real hair) and dark eye brows. The trick to get the red eyebrows and not have it look super fake and weird is to opt for a darker red liner pencil, I prefer the reddish wine colors myself and very lightly fill in your eyebrows (only in the center, if you must line the border of the eyebrow do so very lightly so it still looks natural), this will create a much more harmonious tone. If you insist on a lighter red, use both a darker reddish wine color, and a lighter red together.
"Imagination is the Preview of Life's Coming Attractions"
~ Albert Einstein