I'm suspicious of eBay, so I would go with either a Cosworx Scruffy
in Shadow Red ($26) or an Arda Magnum
in Maroon (normally $30, but Arda is having a 15% off sale next weekend which would bring the price down to around $25). This
cosplayer used a Magnum for Matt and looks great, although she went with the anime version of the color.
~For Anime Milwaukee 2014~
Prince Zuko--Avatar:TLA, "Zuko Alone"
Light Yagami--Death Note, "Ally"
Eren Jaeger--Shingeki no Kyojin, "Can't Look Into His Eyes"
Shirt/Pants/Wig/Boots/Bruise and Blood Makeup