Originally Posted by Amion
What do you guys thing? Win or Fail?
kiratsukai was just giving her opinion to try to help you improve. Also it's hard to tell what the shorts are made out of from a picture. At first I though jean too ^^;
What is a good idea, as to actually show everyone how you really want it to look, why not cosplay him again and have a mini shoot in your house (where it's warm!
). Then everyone can see what it's like without the tights etc~
For the hat on the head, it seems like with the eyepatch on that side along with the hat, there is too much going on, on that side. Try to put the hat on the other side (like in your drawing).
With all original designs, there can be tweaking. In the photo that you have, the pants don't look straight (they may be, but in that photo they don't).
As kiratsukai said, with the socks, when I googled Ciel (as I don't watch the show, i know it because it's popular), the majority of pictures had him with socks just below the knee with a sock garter and the knee socks that I did see had no ruffles.
In the end though, it is your Original Design but there is always room for tweaking. Try small different tweaks with the costume on, as on a piece of paper, it's a different thing.