Your skintone is fine. If it's accuarcy you are looking for Tifa's makeup is more tan/browns and pinks. Nude/soft pink lipstick, soft pink blush, tan/suede eyeshadow sweep over lid to crease followed by dark brown shadow (or liner if you want a more intense effect) using an angle or flat-head eye brush to line around the top and bottom lash lines. Draw the line thicker and heavier on the top lash line and blend well and close to the eye on the bottom lash line. Products to try: Smashbox lipstick in Nude or Lorac Lipstick in Premier, Dior Blush in Fresh Pink, Clinique Coffee Shop Duo or ones similar to these.
Hardly on anymore. Life happens.